[{"issue":"7339","abstract":[{"text":"Nowak et al.1 argue that inclusive fitness theory has been of little value in explaining the natural world, and that it has led to negligible progress in explaining the evolution of eusociality. However, we believe that their arguments are based upon a misunderstanding of evolutionary theory and a misrepresentation of the empirical literature. We will focus our comments on three general issues.","lang":"eng"}],"type":"journal_article","oa_version":"Submitted Version","intvolume":" 471","status":"public","title":"Inclusive fitness theory and eusociality","_id":"3372","user_id":"2DF688A6-F248-11E8-B48F-1D18A9856A87","day":"23","scopus_import":1,"date_published":"2011-03-23T00:00:00Z","page":"E1 - E4","citation":{"short":"P. Abbot, J. Abe, J. Alcock, S. Alizon, J. Alpedrinha, M. Andersson, J. Andre, M. Van Baalen, F. Balloux, S. Balshine, N.H. Barton, L. Beukeboom, J. Biernaskie, T. Bilde, G. Borgia, M. Breed, S. Brown, R. Bshary, A. Buckling, N. Burley, M. Burton Chellew, M. Cant, M. Chapuisat, E. Charnov, T. Clutton Brock, A. Cockburn, B. Cole, N. Colegrave, L. Cosmides, I. Couzin, J. Coyne, S. Creel, B. Crespi, R. Curry, S. Dall, T. Day, J. Dickinson, L. Dugatkin, C. El Mouden, S. Emlen, J. Evans, R. Ferriere, J. Field, S. Foitzik, K. Foster, W. Foster, C. Fox, J. Gadau, S. Gandon, A. Gardner, M. Gardner, T. Getty, M. Goodisman, A. Grafen, R. Grosberg, C. Grozinger, P. Gouyon, D. Gwynne, P. Harvey, B. Hatchwell, J. Heinze, H. Helantera, K. Helms, K. Hill, N. Jiricny, R. Johnstone, A. Kacelnik, E.T. Kiers, H. Kokko, J. Komdeur, J. Korb, D. Kronauer, R. Kümmerli, L. Lehmann, T. Linksvayer, S. Lion, B. Lyon, J. Marshall, R. Mcelreath, Y. Michalakis, R. Michod, D. Mock, T. Monnin, R. Montgomerie, A. Moore, U. Mueller, R. Noë, S. Okasha, P. Pamilo, G. Parker, J. Pedersen, I. Pen, D. Pfennig, D. Queller, D. Rankin, S. Reece, H. Reeve, M. Reuter, G. Roberts, S. Robson, D. Roze, F. Rousset, O. Rueppell, J. Sachs, L. Santorelli, P. Schmid Hempel, M. Schwarz, T. Scott Phillips, J. Shellmann Sherman, P. Sherman, D. Shuker, J. Smith, J. Spagna, B. Strassmann, A. Suarez, L. Sundström, M. Taborsky, P. Taylor, G. Thompson, J. Tooby, N. Tsutsui, K. Tsuji, S. Turillazzi, F. Úbeda, E. Vargo, B. Voelkl, T. Wenseleers, S. West, M. West Eberhard, D. Westneat, D. Wiernasz, G. Wild, R. Wrangham, A. Young, D. Zeh, J. Zeh, A. Zink, Nature 471 (2011) E1–E4.","mla":"Abbot, Patrick, et al. “Inclusive Fitness Theory and Eusociality.” Nature, vol. 471, no. 7339, Nature Publishing Group, 2011, pp. E1–4, doi:10.1038/nature09831.","chicago":"Abbot, Patrick, Jun Abe, John Alcock, Samuel Alizon, Joao Alpedrinha, Malte Andersson, Jean Andre, et al. “Inclusive Fitness Theory and Eusociality.” Nature. Nature Publishing Group, 2011. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature09831.","ama":"Abbot P, Abe J, Alcock J, et al. Inclusive fitness theory and eusociality. Nature. 2011;471(7339):E1-E4. doi:10.1038/nature09831","apa":"Abbot, P., Abe, J., Alcock, J., Alizon, S., Alpedrinha, J., Andersson, M., … Zink, A. (2011). Inclusive fitness theory and eusociality. Nature. Nature Publishing Group. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature09831","ieee":"P. Abbot et al., “Inclusive fitness theory and eusociality,” Nature, vol. 471, no. 7339. Nature Publishing Group, pp. E1–E4, 2011.","ista":"Abbot P et al. 2011. Inclusive fitness theory and eusociality. Nature. 471(7339), E1–E4."},"publication":"Nature","publist_id":"3237","volume":471,"date_created":"2018-12-11T12:02:57Z","date_updated":"2021-01-12T07:43:02Z","author":[{"full_name":"Abbot, Patrick","last_name":"Abbot","first_name":"Patrick"},{"full_name":"Abe, Jun","first_name":"Jun","last_name":"Abe"},{"full_name":"Alcock, John","last_name":"Alcock","first_name":"John"},{"full_name":"Alizon, Samuel","last_name":"Alizon","first_name":"Samuel"},{"first_name":"Joao","last_name":"Alpedrinha","full_name":"Alpedrinha, Joao"},{"full_name":"Andersson, Malte","first_name":"Malte","last_name":"Andersson"},{"full_name":"Andre, Jean","first_name":"Jean","last_name":"Andre"},{"full_name":"Van Baalen, Minus","first_name":"Minus","last_name":"Van Baalen"},{"full_name":"Balloux, Francois","first_name":"Francois","last_name":"Balloux"},{"last_name":"Balshine","first_name":"Sigal","full_name":"Balshine, Sigal"},{"full_name":"Barton, Nicholas H","last_name":"Barton","first_name":"Nicholas H","orcid":"0000-0002-8548-5240","id":"4880FE40-F248-11E8-B48F-1D18A9856A87"},{"first_name":"Leo","last_name":"Beukeboom","full_name":"Beukeboom, Leo"},{"first_name":"Jay","last_name":"Biernaskie","full_name":"Biernaskie, Jay"},{"full_name":"Bilde, Trine","last_name":"Bilde","first_name":"Trine"},{"full_name":"Borgia, Gerald","last_name":"Borgia","first_name":"Gerald"},{"first_name":"Michael","last_name":"Breed","full_name":"Breed, Michael"},{"first_name":"Sam","last_name":"Brown","full_name":"Brown, Sam"},{"full_name":"Bshary, Redouan","first_name":"Redouan","last_name":"Bshary"},{"last_name":"Buckling","first_name":"Angus","full_name":"Buckling, Angus"},{"full_name":"Burley, Nancy","last_name":"Burley","first_name":"Nancy"},{"full_name":"Burton Chellew, Max","first_name":"Max","last_name":"Burton Chellew"},{"full_name":"Cant, Michael","last_name":"Cant","first_name":"Michael"},{"full_name":"Chapuisat, Michel","first_name":"Michel","last_name":"Chapuisat"},{"first_name":"Eric","last_name":"Charnov","full_name":"Charnov, Eric"},{"full_name":"Clutton Brock, Tim","first_name":"Tim","last_name":"Clutton Brock"},{"last_name":"Cockburn","first_name":"Andrew","full_name":"Cockburn, Andrew"},{"full_name":"Cole, Blaine","first_name":"Blaine","last_name":"Cole"},{"first_name":"Nick","last_name":"Colegrave","full_name":"Colegrave, Nick"},{"full_name":"Cosmides, Leda","last_name":"Cosmides","first_name":"Leda"},{"full_name":"Couzin, Iain","first_name":"Iain","last_name":"Couzin"},{"last_name":"Coyne","first_name":"Jerry","full_name":"Coyne, Jerry"},{"first_name":"Scott","last_name":"Creel","full_name":"Creel, Scott"},{"first_name":"Bernard","last_name":"Crespi","full_name":"Crespi, Bernard"},{"full_name":"Curry, Robert","last_name":"Curry","first_name":"Robert"},{"last_name":"Dall","first_name":"Sasha","full_name":"Dall, Sasha"},{"full_name":"Day, Troy","first_name":"Troy","last_name":"Day"},{"full_name":"Dickinson, Janis","last_name":"Dickinson","first_name":"Janis"},{"first_name":"Lee","last_name":"Dugatkin","full_name":"Dugatkin, Lee"},{"full_name":"El Mouden, Claire","first_name":"Claire","last_name":"El Mouden"},{"first_name":"Stephen","last_name":"Emlen","full_name":"Emlen, Stephen"},{"full_name":"Evans, Jay","last_name":"Evans","first_name":"Jay"},{"first_name":"Regis","last_name":"Ferriere","full_name":"Ferriere, Regis"},{"last_name":"Field","first_name":"Jeremy","full_name":"Field, Jeremy"},{"first_name":"Susanne","last_name":"Foitzik","full_name":"Foitzik, Susanne"},{"full_name":"Foster, Kevin","first_name":"Kevin","last_name":"Foster"},{"last_name":"Foster","first_name":"William","full_name":"Foster, William"},{"full_name":"Fox, Charles","first_name":"Charles","last_name":"Fox"},{"full_name":"Gadau, Juergen","last_name":"Gadau","first_name":"Juergen"},{"last_name":"Gandon","first_name":"Sylvain","full_name":"Gandon, Sylvain"},{"last_name":"Gardner","first_name":"Andy","full_name":"Gardner, Andy"},{"first_name":"Michael","last_name":"Gardner","full_name":"Gardner, Michael"},{"full_name":"Getty, Thomas","last_name":"Getty","first_name":"Thomas"},{"full_name":"Goodisman, Michael","first_name":"Michael","last_name":"Goodisman"},{"full_name":"Grafen, Alan","last_name":"Grafen","first_name":"Alan"},{"full_name":"Grosberg, Rick","last_name":"Grosberg","first_name":"Rick"},{"last_name":"Grozinger","first_name":"Christina","full_name":"Grozinger, Christina"},{"full_name":"Gouyon, Pierre","last_name":"Gouyon","first_name":"Pierre"},{"first_name":"Darryl","last_name":"Gwynne","full_name":"Gwynne, Darryl"},{"first_name":"Paul","last_name":"Harvey","full_name":"Harvey, Paul"},{"last_name":"Hatchwell","first_name":"Ben","full_name":"Hatchwell, Ben"},{"first_name":"Jürgen","last_name":"Heinze","full_name":"Heinze, Jürgen"},{"first_name":"Heikki","last_name":"Helantera","full_name":"Helantera, Heikki"},{"first_name":"Ken","last_name":"Helms","full_name":"Helms, Ken"},{"last_name":"Hill","first_name":"Kim","full_name":"Hill, Kim"},{"full_name":"Jiricny, Natalie","last_name":"Jiricny","first_name":"Natalie"},{"full_name":"Johnstone, Rufus","first_name":"Rufus","last_name":"Johnstone"},{"first_name":"Alex","last_name":"Kacelnik","full_name":"Kacelnik, Alex"},{"full_name":"Kiers, E Toby","first_name":"E Toby","last_name":"Kiers"},{"last_name":"Kokko","first_name":"Hanna","full_name":"Kokko, Hanna"},{"full_name":"Komdeur, Jan","first_name":"Jan","last_name":"Komdeur"},{"full_name":"Korb, Judith","last_name":"Korb","first_name":"Judith"},{"first_name":"Daniel","last_name":"Kronauer","full_name":"Kronauer, Daniel"},{"full_name":"Kümmerli, Rolf","first_name":"Rolf","last_name":"Kümmerli"},{"full_name":"Lehmann, Laurent","last_name":"Lehmann","first_name":"Laurent"},{"full_name":"Linksvayer, Timothy","first_name":"Timothy","last_name":"Linksvayer"},{"first_name":"Sébastien","last_name":"Lion","full_name":"Lion, Sébastien"},{"last_name":"Lyon","first_name":"Bruce","full_name":"Lyon, Bruce"},{"full_name":"Marshall, James","first_name":"James","last_name":"Marshall"},{"last_name":"Mcelreath","first_name":"Richard","full_name":"Mcelreath, Richard"},{"first_name":"Yannis","last_name":"Michalakis","full_name":"Michalakis, Yannis"},{"last_name":"Michod","first_name":"Richard","full_name":"Michod, Richard"},{"last_name":"Mock","first_name":"Douglas","full_name":"Mock, Douglas"},{"first_name":"Thibaud","last_name":"Monnin","full_name":"Monnin, Thibaud"},{"last_name":"Montgomerie","first_name":"Robert","full_name":"Montgomerie, Robert"},{"first_name":"Allen","last_name":"Moore","full_name":"Moore, Allen"},{"full_name":"Mueller, Ulrich","first_name":"Ulrich","last_name":"Mueller"},{"full_name":"Noë, Ronald","first_name":"Ronald","last_name":"Noë"},{"last_name":"Okasha","first_name":"Samir","full_name":"Okasha, Samir"},{"last_name":"Pamilo","first_name":"Pekka","full_name":"Pamilo, Pekka"},{"full_name":"Parker, Geoff","first_name":"Geoff","last_name":"Parker"},{"full_name":"Pedersen, Jes","last_name":"Pedersen","first_name":"Jes"},{"full_name":"Pen, Ido","first_name":"Ido","last_name":"Pen"},{"full_name":"Pfennig, David","first_name":"David","last_name":"Pfennig"},{"first_name":"David","last_name":"Queller","full_name":"Queller, David"},{"full_name":"Rankin, Daniel","last_name":"Rankin","first_name":"Daniel"},{"full_name":"Reece, Sarah","first_name":"Sarah","last_name":"Reece"},{"full_name":"Reeve, Hudson","last_name":"Reeve","first_name":"Hudson"},{"full_name":"Reuter, Max","first_name":"Max","last_name":"Reuter"},{"last_name":"Roberts","first_name":"Gilbert","full_name":"Roberts, Gilbert"},{"full_name":"Robson, Simon","first_name":"Simon","last_name":"Robson"},{"full_name":"Roze, Denis","last_name":"Roze","first_name":"Denis"},{"first_name":"Francois","last_name":"Rousset","full_name":"Rousset, Francois"},{"full_name":"Rueppell, Olav","first_name":"Olav","last_name":"Rueppell"},{"last_name":"Sachs","first_name":"Joel","full_name":"Sachs, Joel"},{"full_name":"Santorelli, Lorenzo","first_name":"Lorenzo","last_name":"Santorelli"},{"full_name":"Schmid Hempel, Paul","last_name":"Schmid Hempel","first_name":"Paul"},{"full_name":"Schwarz, Michael","last_name":"Schwarz","first_name":"Michael"},{"full_name":"Scott Phillips, Tom","first_name":"Tom","last_name":"Scott Phillips"},{"last_name":"Shellmann Sherman","first_name":"Janet","full_name":"Shellmann Sherman, Janet"},{"full_name":"Sherman, Paul","last_name":"Sherman","first_name":"Paul"},{"full_name":"Shuker, David","first_name":"David","last_name":"Shuker"},{"full_name":"Smith, Jeff","first_name":"Jeff","last_name":"Smith"},{"full_name":"Spagna, Joseph","first_name":"Joseph","last_name":"Spagna"},{"full_name":"Strassmann, Beverly","last_name":"Strassmann","first_name":"Beverly"},{"full_name":"Suarez, Andrew","first_name":"Andrew","last_name":"Suarez"},{"full_name":"Sundström, Liselotte","first_name":"Liselotte","last_name":"Sundström"},{"last_name":"Taborsky","first_name":"Michael","full_name":"Taborsky, Michael"},{"full_name":"Taylor, Peter","last_name":"Taylor","first_name":"Peter"},{"first_name":"Graham","last_name":"Thompson","full_name":"Thompson, Graham"},{"full_name":"Tooby, John","last_name":"Tooby","first_name":"John"},{"full_name":"Tsutsui, Neil","last_name":"Tsutsui","first_name":"Neil"},{"full_name":"Tsuji, Kazuki","last_name":"Tsuji","first_name":"Kazuki"},{"full_name":"Turillazzi, Stefano","last_name":"Turillazzi","first_name":"Stefano"},{"full_name":"Úbeda, Francisco","last_name":"Úbeda","first_name":"Francisco"},{"last_name":"Vargo","first_name":"Edward","full_name":"Vargo, Edward"},{"full_name":"Voelkl, Bernard","first_name":"Bernard","last_name":"Voelkl"},{"first_name":"Tom","last_name":"Wenseleers","full_name":"Wenseleers, Tom"},{"full_name":"West, Stuart","last_name":"West","first_name":"Stuart"},{"first_name":"Mary","last_name":"West Eberhard","full_name":"West Eberhard, Mary"},{"full_name":"Westneat, David","last_name":"Westneat","first_name":"David"},{"full_name":"Wiernasz, Diane","last_name":"Wiernasz","first_name":"Diane"},{"first_name":"Geoff","last_name":"Wild","full_name":"Wild, Geoff"},{"last_name":"Wrangham","first_name":"Richard","full_name":"Wrangham, Richard"},{"first_name":"Andrew","last_name":"Young","full_name":"Young, Andrew"},{"full_name":"Zeh, David","first_name":"David","last_name":"Zeh"},{"last_name":"Zeh","first_name":"Jeanne","full_name":"Zeh, Jeanne"},{"full_name":"Zink, Andrew","first_name":"Andrew","last_name":"Zink"}],"publisher":"Nature Publishing Group","department":[{"_id":"NiBa"}],"publication_status":"published","pmid":1,"year":"2011","month":"03","language":[{"iso":"eng"}],"doi":"10.1038/nature09831","quality_controlled":"1","external_id":{"pmid":["21430721"]},"main_file_link":[{"open_access":"1","url":"http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3836173/"}],"oa":1}]