Biochemical and structural insights into ADAR1 RNA editing

ADAR1 is broadly expressed across various tissues and is vital in regulating pathways associated with innate immune responses. ADAR1 marks double-stranded RNA as "self" through its A-to-I editing activity, effectively repressing autoimmunity and maintaining immune tolerance. This editing process has been detected at millions of sites across the human genome. However, the mechanism underlying ADAR1's substrate selectivity properties remains largely unclear, with much of the current knowledge derived from comparisons to its more extensively studied homolog, ADAR2. By studying ADAR1 in complex with its RNA substrates and applying a combination of biochemical techniques and structural studies using CryoEM, we aim to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the substrate selectivity characteristics of ADAR1. In this thesis, the purification protocol for ADAR1 was successfully optimized, resulting in the first report in the literature to achieve high protein purity and activity. This advancement enabled the investigation of complex formation between ADAR1 and various RNA substrates, leading to the identification of optimal conditions for preparing the cryoEM sample. However, despite comprehensive optimization of the cryo-EM conditions, the resulting data lacked the desired quality, highlighting the need for similar rigorous optimization of the RNA substrates to facilitate structural studies of the ADAR1-RNA complex. The study was complemented by AlphaFold predictions, which provided some insights into this mechanism. Moreover, during this project I established a collaboration with a research group focused on studying ADAR homologs. Notably ADAR homologs were identified in bivalve species, and it was further demonstrated that ADAR and its A-to-I editing activity are upregulated in Pacific oysters during infections with Ostreid herpesvirus-1—a highly infectious virus that leads to significant losses in oyster populations globally. I successfully purified oyster ADAR and prepared in vitro edited RNA for nanopore sequencing—a direct sequencing technology capable of detecting modified nucleotides without the need for reverse transcription. The collaborators initiated optimization of this nanopore-based approach. However, current technological limitations still constrain the reliable detection of modified nucleotides. The project also examined the impact of RNA editing on RNA binding and filament formation by MDA5, a key cytosolic dsRNA sensor that triggers an interferon response. A primary target of ADAR1's editing activity is RNA derived from repetitive elements present in the genome, particularly Alu elements forming double-stranded RNA. When unedited, these RNA sequences are recognized by MDA5. However, the mechanisms by which MDA5 interacts with Alu RNAs, as well as the role of A-to-I editing in influencing this binding, are still not well understood. The interaction between MDA5 and Alu elements, was successfully established. This was achieved through the testing of different RNA variants and the evaluation of filament formation using binding techniques and electron microscopy imaging. This groundwork has set the conditions for further evaluation using CryoEM. Furthermore, the effects of A-to-I editing on the binding properties of MDA5 with Alu RNA were investigated. Given the recent research that has provided new insights into MDA5's interaction with dsRNA, it is essential to revise the experimental setup to integrate these findings before moving forward with the CryoEM sample analysis.